4.18.2007

Emptiness

Before I sicken myself further in the process of trying to come to terms with this mass murder, here I will (progressively) dump the thoughts that have been eating at me the past two days.

Things I have in common with Cho Seung Hui

  • Asian

  • Male

  • Immigrant parents (he was first generation, I was second, born here)

  • Grew up in the South

  • English major



All this amounts to is that, on the surface, we both faced the same set of circumstances growing up, and the way we dealt with these "cards" made us who we are/were. For those who can't imagine what this means, let me suggest a one significant factor.

The Immigrant's Dilemma
Pick one:

The reality created by your parents at home

or

the world you face when you get dropped off to go to school


This is the dilemma faced by every first and second generation immigrant. Do you hold on to the values of your motherland, or do you embrace the values of the land to which you have come? For children of immigrant parents this is particularly difficult. The motherland is a distant memory compared to the overwhelming power of the here and now.

Who am I? Seung Hui asks himself. Where do I fit? In one world,

  • Grades are a matter of life or death

  • Filial piety is paramount (if you don't understand what this means, you probably aren't of this world)

  • Self-expression is not important or encouraged

  • Personal happiness is secondary to academic/financial success

  • Sex? Forget about it.

  • Dating is not even an option (it'll happen after you're rich)

  • Studying is the only thing you should be doing with your time outside of school

  • Friends are fine, as long as they are not miscreants and they do not interfere with your studies



In addition to this obvious desire to make your parents happy, is the fact that they have sacrificed everything to get you the opportunity to succeed in this beautiful country (mei guo). The path has been laid out for you before you were even born.

There is a price for embracing this path, however. You will be ridiculed (for having good grades, for studying all the time, for looking different, for wearing dorky clothes, for having an idiotic haircut, for not having any social skills). You will be emasculated. Your ego will be crushed on a daily basis. You might die without ever having sex.

The world outside taunts you
Middle America: a world and a worldview reinforced daily on television and in the social battlefield of the classroom and the schoolyard. It is a world you can only hope to be accepted in. You have, after all, been dealt the worst possible cards for survival in a world that is:

  • Muscular

  • Highly sexed

  • Violent, aggressive

  • Emotive

  • Christian

  • Righteous



I hear you, whispering about me. I see how you look at me. I will not open my mouth to respond. Instead, I will respond with violence. You make fun of my voice, of what I say, of how I say it? I will learn your language and twist it with vengeance to release my wrath.


Regardless of your race or ethnicity, in every human being's genetic material is the desire to survive, to fit into the collective, to do whatever it takes to achieve security. His seething rage overruled this primary instinct.

Everything that has surfaced about him convinces me that he was empty, that's the only word I can find to describe it.

I can see him not speaking to anyone, knowing that if he opened his mouth to speak, his bile would spill out uncontrollably. So he shut his mouth tight, and vomited, first, onto the page, in his room, alone, and later, in the world outside, he would perform his final act of expulsion.

3 comments:

Last Day Emails said...

He came here when he was 8 and yet at twenty-something, was still not a citizen. That bites. I can't imagine how that feels...

Unknown said...

The Immigrant's Dilemma is so interesting! What a great way to get to the crux of the issue, and I completely second that.

But you missed something on the parents' list:

-Piano or violin, take your pick.
-You're never as good as so-and-so's kid.

But honestly, these traits aren't singularly isolated to Asians. Filial piety is also important to many other cultures, such as Italians (from first-hand experience with my very very Italian boyfriend's family). The difference is, these traits are more often seen as negative for Asians. Even if you really do naturally excel in math and science, showing that is almost like feeding into a negative stereotype. Also, when you work hard to achieve a good grade, your peers often attribute your success to being Asian, and not to your hard work. Basically, being Asian predisposes you to know how to calculate the derivative of a curve.
But, Cho's sister is the wild card in this, I think. She graduated from Princeton and is seemingly well-adjusted. Perhaps even it is because of her success that triggered such a hard fall for him? Just purely speculating.

Caroline Skelton Priebe said...

meng. i agree filial piety is important in other cultures or just a specific family for that matter. i grew up in a sort of northern european mutt family? we all worked at our family business (including children starting at age 11) and three generations lived next to eachother. family duty/responsibilty superceded ALL else. the elders were/are WELL taken care of in sickness and health. family members moving back to wisconsin to care for sick ones. not to mention the everyday royal treatment the grandmothers (yes, the women) received. my grandmother thought it was silly i went away to college, when she/the family could teach me everything i needed to know right there :)

but. i also wanted to comment on why cho's sister might be so well-adjusted. two thoughts. one, is their less pressure on her because she is female?
second, it is my belief that cho may have had some sort of central nervous system disorder which made him ill-equipped to handle this harsh world?
not that anything is really comparable or that i would have any idea what this kid went through, but there are a lot of people exposed to chronic injustice who don't snap go on a shooting rampage? one of my "well adjusted" girlfriends grew up in mississippi. she was reminding me last week how she was teased relentlessly as a kid/pre-teen. kids used to call her "little nigger" and throw dirt on her. she's 1/2 philipino, 1/2 irish.